Stacking 5-star reviews and reaching Top Rated on Fiverr
Level 1, Level 2 and Top Rated thresholds explained, plus the method to turn every order into a 5-star review without begging.
Fiverr levels aren’t cosmetic. They unlock features (extra gigs, faster withdrawals, Buyer Requests access), and the algorithm favors higher levels in search. Here’s how to clear each tier cleanly.
The exact thresholds
Level 1: 60 days active, 10 orders, $400 revenue, 4.7+ rating, 90% response, 90% on-time delivery, 90% completion. Level 2: 120 days, 50 orders, $2,000. Top Rated Seller: 180 days, 100 orders, $20,000, and manual Fiverr selection.
Ask for a review without annoying
The post-delivery message should be short, natural, explicit. "If you’re happy with the result, a quick review helps me a lot to keep offering this service." That’s it. Ask ONCE, not three times. Any message pushing for 5 stars is a violation, so avoid.
Handle risky orders
Spot vague buyers in 30 seconds (fuzzy briefs, requirements outside the package, aggressive first message). Restate in writing what you will deliver AND what you won’t. If the brief stays unclear after two exchanges, send a tailored Custom Offer, or politely decline.
Key takeaways
- Reply within 5 minutes of delivery to any question: it locks in a positive review.
- NEVER ask explicitly for 5 stars: it’s a sanctioned violation.
- If a buyer threatens a bad review to extort a refund, contact Fiverr support before accepting.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 4-star review really bad?
Yes. Fiverr averages are high (>4.8). Dropping to 4.7 costs you impressions. If a 4-star lands, no panic: stack 5 excellent orders to dilute.
Can I refuse a problematic buyer?
Yes, and you MUST do it before accepting the order. Once started, refusing = cancellation = penalty.
Read next
Other tool guides
Disclosure: some links to Fiverr are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, I earn a commission at no extra cost to you.